In the News

Sci-Fi from the Stanley Simon Estate Breaks Records in Swann Literature Auction

New York—Science fiction ruled on May 15 at Swann Galleries’ auction of 19th &... read more

MoMA Announces Major Acquisitions from the Merrill C. Berman Collection

New York—The Museum of Modern Art has acquired more than 300 masterworks of The... read more

Sunday Comics & "New Yorker" Covers Lead Swann's Sale of Illustration Art

New York — Swann Galleries will offer an auction of Illustration Art on Tuesday,... read more

Original Tintin Art by Hergé May Bring $720,000 in Heritage's First European Comic Art Auction

Dallas, TX - An extraordinary, 12-panel page of Original Tintin Art by Belgian cartoonist... read more

Highlights of Christie's Spring Sales of Books & Manuscripts to be Held on June 14

New York—Christie’s announces the spring various owner sale of Fine Printed Books & Manuscripts... read more

"Medieval/Modern": Dr. Jörn Günther Rare Books Will Open Exhibition to Complement Art Basel

Complementing Art Basel 2018, Dr. Jörn Günther Rare Books will open its doors for... read more

New England Society Book Awards Winners Announced

New York—The NES Book Awards are made in four categories: Art & Photography, Fiction,... read more

World Record Comic Book & Art Auction Surpasses $12.2 Million at Heritage Auctions

Dallas, TX - Chicago’s largest public auction dedicated to vintage comic books and original... read more

Follow us on TwitterLike us on Facebook
Auction Guide
Advertise with Us
2015 Bookseller Resource Guide
Feature

The Lost Libraries of London

A distinctive walking tour through one of the world’s great book towns focuses on historic collections dispersed by auction, war, and fire By A. N. Devers A. N. Devers is a writer, editor, and rare bookseller who lives in London. Her first book, Train, is forthcoming from Bloomsbury in 2018.

Dr. Samuel Johnson, the son of a bookseller, became one of the great literary figures of the eighteenth century. He was a critic, a poet, a lexicographer—and a book collector, too, although his collection was rather infamously disbanded at auction in 1785. Reproduced by courtesy of the Trustees of Dr. Johnson’s House

On February 16, 1785, three months after Dr. Samuel Johnson died, James Christie, the founder of Christie’s auction house, held a historic four-day auction of approximately three thousand volumes belonging to the Dictionary of the English Language author’s library.

Christie had been auctioning books for fifteen years, but selling the preeminent critic a language expert’s collection was a career-defining feather in his cap. Unfortunately for scholars, the catalogue produced for the sale is considered an example of what should not be done with a book auction catalogue, with many entries lacking proper titles, keeping scholars at a distance from what is arguably a keystone collection for studying the history of the English language and its origins.

Located at 17 Gough Square, Dr. Johnson’s House, now a house museum, is one of the stops along Alice Ford-Smith’s walking tour of London’s Lost Libraries. Reproduced by courtesy of the Trustees of Dr. Johnson’s House.
The catalogue issued by James Christie when he offered Dr. Johnson’s library at auction in 1785. This copy is held by the Hyde Collection at Harvard’s Houghton Library. Credit: Houghton Library, Harvard University. *2003J-SJ1172b.

At a fifteenth-anniversary Johnson Club dinner in Oxford celebrating Johnson’s work, the nineteenth-century clergyman and scholar, A. W. Hutton, handed out facsimiles of Christie’s catalogue while commenting on its poor quality, “ … when we turn to the catalogue itself, it is but a very sorry production, sadly unworthy of the occasion that called it into existence.” For example, there were thirty-six total grammar books, or “grammars,” listed, but that is all that is known about them, so academics must do text comparisons between the dictionary and possible book titles to piece together the gaps. Still, the catalogue gives scholars and collectors a general idea of what Johnson had at his fingertips while working on the dictionary. There were sermons, classical literature, philosophy, medical books, poetry and drama, and more. He had Milton’s Paradise Lost and plenty of copies of his own books.

“The whole amount realized was £242 9s,” Hutton reported of the auction total, “being at an average of about nineteen pence a volume, a truly lamentable result, considering that the library included many valuable editions of the classics printed in the sixteenth century, and the first folio edition of Shakespeare, which, if in good condition, as it probably was not, ought to have fetched more than the whole library went for.”

Hutton was wrong about Johnson’s Shakespeare—it was a second edition—but he was right to be offended by the result of the auction. In hindsight, the enormous import of Johnson’s library as formative to the first English dictionary is immeasurable, and it would have been beneficial and prudent to keep it together. Since its dispersal, Johnson’s books have been highly sought after and commanded high prices, despite being, as Hutton suggested of his apocryphal Shakespeare, in poor condition. Luckily for Johnson collectors, this also makes them identifiable—he annotated heavily and signed his name in most of them, as I first learned from Alice Ford-Smith, while standing outside Dr. Johnson’s House, on her walking tour of London’s “Lost Libraries.”

Page 1 | 2 | 3 | Next