In the News

The Morgan Presents Tolkien's Adventurous Tales and Original Illustrations

New York — This winter, the Morgan Library & Museum offers a once-in-a-generation opportunity... read more

Al Hirschfeld's Marx Brothers Drawing Tops Illustration Art Auction

New York­-Swann Galleries’ auction of Illustration Art on December 6 saw a bustling auction... read more

The Roger Casson Library of Polar Exploration, Travel & Local History Heads to Auction

An important private library of polar exploration, travel and local history books, including many... read more

Original Star Wars Designs Achieve Top Lot at Bonhams

London--A sketchbook showing the original hand-drawn costume designs for key characters in Star Wars... read more

The Getty Museum Presents "Artful Words: Calligraphy in Illuminated Manuscripts"

Los Angeles - The written word was a major art form in the premodern... read more

Olmsted's 1859 Letter Describing his Vision for Central Park to be Auctioned

Los Angeles - A handwritten letter from renowned landscape architect Frederick Law Olmsted to... read more

Works by Tolkien, Drawings, and Photography on View This Winter at the Morgan

New York — The 2019 winter season at the Morgan Library & Museum continues... read more

Sotheby's Geek Week Auctions Total $7.4 Million in NY

New York - Sotheby’s Geek Week auctions concluded Friday in New York with a... read more

Follow us on TwitterLike us on Facebook
Auction Guide
Advertise with Us
2015 Bookseller Resource Guide
Digest
Courtesy of Don Bearden.

Unpacking Twain’s Trunk

One man’s shabby auction find may very well be a literary treasure chest By Jonathan Shipley Jonathan Shipley is a freelance writer living in Seattle. He’s written for such varied publications as the Los Angeles Times, Gather Journal and Lexus Magazine. One of his prized possessions is a first edition of Mark Twain’s Roughing It.

The story seems as far-fetched as Mark Twain’s tall tales. A man, who by day crafts and restores stained glass, happened by an old trunk at an auction in Kansas City, Missouri, in early 2015. The words ‘Property of Samuel L. Clemens’ applied in black paint caught his eye. A lifelong fan of the American author born Samuel L. Clemens but better known as Mark Twain, the browser’s interest was piqued. He purchased the tatty antique and began a yearlong quest to verify its authenticity.

A leather trunk purchased at auction in 2015 sent its buyer on a research mission to verify its literary provenance. Courtesy of Don Bearden.

He studied trunk manufacturing of the 1860s. He employed forensic scientists and art conservators. He had conversations with the FBI about stray white hairs he found inside the trunk. He had sodium chloride tests done to ascertain the makeup of the grime on the trunk’s surface. He used microscopes, ultraviolet light, and magnifying glasses, all to learn more about the hand-tooled leather trunk and the famous man who once owned it.

“It is time,” Twain wrote in a letter dated April 29, 1869, “I was thinking about packing my trunk.” Since the fateful day Don Bearden purchased it for himself, he’s been trying to unpack the trunk’s history and Twain’s life with it, bit by bit. “Instinctually I knew it was his trunk—after all, his name is on it,” Bearden said. “However, I wanted to go much deeper to discover the trunk’s origin of manufacture, history, and existence. I wanted to establish provenance.”

Deeper he’s gone, with shelves full of Twain books of his own, and help from such varied sources as historical societies, museums, and universities, including Elmira College’s Center for Mark Twain Studies and the Mark Twain Project at the University of California, Berkeley. “Each step in this process has been absolutely thrilling,” he said.

The first break happened at the Missouri History Museum Library and Research Center in St. Louis. In an 1865–66 Saint Louis City Directory there was a listing for a J. Barwick Trunk Manufacturer on Olive Street. A Barwick label is affixed to the trunk. (Who lived in Saint Louis for a short time in 1867? Twain, that’s who.) Bearden was hooked to learn more—like that the font Louize Bold, which was used on the trunk for the name Clemens, was the same font used in many of Twain’s published books; that the stenciling on the underside of the lid was very similar to the design used on the book cover of The Adventures of Tom Sawyer; that after one bottles the muck on the trunk’s surface, it smells like smoke. “As extraordinary as it may seem, you can still experience his presence with that trunk,” Bearden said after sniffing the tobacco residue from the vial. “It was amazing.”

He took the trunk to PBS’s Antiques Roadshow when it stopped in Little Rock, Arkansas, and was offered the chance to be on-air, but declined because he thought the trunk was worth well more than the appraisal submitted by the show’s experts. As he continues to compile evidence that his chest really is a treasure, he hopes to write an e-book about the trunk and foresees a time when he might sell it to a museum or an institution.

“It’s the discovery of the unknown,” Bearden said. “It’s a rush. For a history buff it’s the Holy Grail experience.”

Jonathan Shipley is a freelance writer living in Seattle. He’s written for such varied publications as the Los Angeles Times, Gather Journal and Lexus Magazine. One of his prized possessions is a first edition of Mark Twain’s Roughing It.