In the News

Newly Discovered Draft of Frost's "Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening" at Bonhams

The definitive draft of Robert Frost’s poem Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening... read more

The Huntington to Open Exhibition of Henry Moore Prints on June 16

San Marino, CA— An exhibition focused on the surprising diversity of styles and subject... read more

Irving Penn's "Cuzco Children" Could Bring $150K at Heritage Auctions' June 5 Auction

Dallas, Texas - A powerful image by American photographer Irving Penn could bring as... read more

Results from Potter & Potter Auctions' May 19 Gambling Memorabilia Event

Chicago — Collectors hit the jackpot at Potter & Potter's recent gambling memorabilia sale.... read more

Potter & Potter Auctions' June 16 Sale to Feature the David Baldwin Magic Collection

Chicago — Potter & Potter Auctions is pleased to announce the 435 lot David... read more

Heritage Auctions Announces Sponsorship of Norman Rockwell Museum's "Four Freedoms" Tour

Dallas, Texas - Heritage Auctions (, the largest auction house founded in the United... read more

Bonhams to Auction Movie Posters and Memorabilia From Robert Osborne’s Personal Collection

New York—Bonhams and Turner Classic Movies (TCM) today announced Bonhams and TCM Present ...... read more

Einstein Manuscript & Presidential Autographs Featured at RR Auction

Boston—An important Albert Einstein handwritten manuscript will be auctioned by Boston-based RR Auction. The... read more

Follow us on TwitterLike us on Facebook
Auction Guide
Advertise with Us
2015 Bookseller Resource Guide
Beyond the Basics

Collecting Old Books on a Budget

Because part of a later leaf is missing from this seventeenth-century Latin book by William Camden, and there are also some leaves of the index that are lacking, it would be affordable to an unprejudiced collector. Courtesy of the Lilly Library, Indiana University, Bloomington, Indiana.

Be Forgiving About Condition

Collectors in every field know that condition plays an important role in the price of an item, and that pieces in less-than-fine condition can be difficult to sell or trade, since most collectors will reject them. Since so few collectors or institutions want these books, incomplete copies of common works are often priced significantly below their perfect counterparts. If you can regard positively what is still present in a volume, rather than fretting over what has gone missing over the years, your range of potential acquisitions may grow significantly.

Assemble Sets from Odd Volumes

The Internet has given collectors a better-than-ever chance of assembling sets over time by buying individual volumes that have become separated from their companions, and putting together their own sets, mismatched though they might be. While even small parts of an important multi-volume set might still be expensive, lesser works can sometimes be obtained very inexpensively this way, assuming, of course, that the missing volumes actually do appear eventually.

Look for Later Editions

First editions usually sell for a great deal more than do subsequent editions, and these second or later editions can be quite rewarding to read and to collect. There were often a great many textual and other changes made in later editions, and since many of these changes have not yet been recorded by bibliographers, there is always the potential for making interesting discoveries.

Less Is More: Buy Few Books Rather than Many

If none of the suggestions above appeal to you, and you still want to buy fine copies of books by popular authors or those in sought-after fields, then you may want to consider making each book purchase a rare and special occasion. Collectors’ manuals sometimes advise beginning collectors to make their initial purchases in their newly-chosen area the most expensive and difficult-to-find books that they can afford, based on the idea that these are the books that are likeliest to rise to unaffordable levels. This advice is usually hard to follow, because book collectors enjoy acquiring books, and starting with an expensive one means that you may not be able to buy another for quite some time. But if you are able to collect this way, and you spend nearly all your annual book budget on a single item, eventually you’ll have a small but wonderful library, with nothing to explain or apologize for if another collector happens to see your books.

But if you don’t think that this approach can work for you, and you still want to be surrounded by the books that you’ve read about in the memoirs of famous collectors and booksellers, then I can enthusiastically recommend the profession of special collections librarianship.

Further Reading and Browsing

I’ve written in earlier columns about some of these aspects of collecting, including books in other languages (Spring 2011), incomplete books (Spring 2014), and later editions (Autumn 2011). But whatever collecting approach you take, one of the most important and rewarding things that you can do is to read as much as you can about whatever you’re collecting. Coin collectors are frequently advised to “buy the book before you buy the coin,” and this advice makes good sense for book collectors as well. If you’re going to collect books intelligently, you need to learn as much as you can about the books that you intend to buy, and this mean buying, and reading, reference books before you buy the books that you want to collect. Learning about what you’re collecting allows you to see attributes and connections that aren’t obvious to others, and you’ll be able to add books to your collection before other collectors realize how important these books really are. Bibliographies, catalogues, and other reference works are also among the biggest bargains available in today’s book market, and many of these books sell for far less than they did twenty-five years ago. And you just might become so interested in them that they form a collecting field of their own.

Joel Silver is Director and Curator of Books at the Lilly Library, Indiana University, Bloomington, Indiana.
Page 1 | 2 | End